Since it's just a free mod and everyone can check for themselves I was unsure about doing a quick review but will try to give some constructive criticism. My initial reaction playing thorugh the mod was not very good. Since I'm fed up with anything related with DNF I almost bashed it on the forums because it did many things wrong the same way DNF did and everybody was praising it as the greatest mod ever, but I waited so I could do a fair analysis.
The level design consist of several linear corridors/small linear open areas with little freedom to explore so it basically took the opposite direction Duke 3D did (taking Hollywood Hollocaust as an example, you had a bazillion of paths even though they share the same end) and went through the same way DNF did (linear corridor shooters like the Lady Killer interior and small linear paths like Vegas Streets). They are very detailed, visually speaking, but it doesn't help if gameplay is lacking. Many times you end up locked in cutscenes and you can't move or skip them in any way, which, as I alwyas say, is not so bad the first time but totally kills replayability and annoy the player if he dies and have to watch to the same script over and over.
The sounds used in game have varying quality and the ones taken directly from the trailers are the worst ones. In this case the best to do is either record them yourself or take them off completely, the subtitles would do the job well.
On the bright side, the motorcycle bits were fun to play, but just like DNF there was few things to do besides driving in a straight line. It had more potential for uses in battle, if the player could shoot while riding it would be much better - think something like the DukeBike mod briefly used on DukePlus. You could also take a few notes from the motorcycle maps on Redneck Rampage RA, where you could leave the vehicle to explore and find goodies across the roads.
Some of the new sprites were also well done and it was fun to fight the berseker pigcops and the terminators, but the last boss was... well, let's say it was weird.
In the end,
I've seen better user levels that recieved much less attention than this mod. Just like the real DNF it relied purely on nostalgia and recycled trailer content and from a mod that was advertised as what DNF should have been, using the same methods of the game criticised is not the best way to go.
tl;dr: DNF 2011 with bad graphics. If I had to give a score (0 to 10) it would be around 6.
EDIT:
Forge, on 02 May 2013 - 04:54 AM, said:
edit: such interesting reaction to the post. apparently i'm not the only one who's sensitive. i just couldn't get enough lolz so i might as well go for broke to shove it in your face some more like a big floppy moldy dick
You are derailing the topic to post trolling that can eventually make a flame war and is not even funny.
Try better next time.