Phredreeke, on 12 January 2023 - 01:42 AM, said:
I think you're misunderstanding the HYEOAB meme.
I probably am.
Phredreeke, on 12 January 2023 - 01:42 AM, said:
Further, the reason I posted those discord messages were because of how ludicrous they were. No one actually agrees with Yura.
I've heard people voicing similar opinions before though. They're not entirely invalid, but all of this is one big grey area. Personally I find it counter-productive to view the issue of "freeclones" in terms of "legality", because in practice it inevitably boils down to whether the copyright holder is willing to threaten legal action, issue C&Ds and so on or not, and sometimes companies go to ridiculous extremes like taking down demo versions that've been available for years, or that one time when id Software interfered with a guy who wanted to register the name Doomscroll for his band, just to name a few examples.
There are also cases (including some games on the list I posted) where the author of a remake knows that the original developers or copyright holders are aware of said remake project, but since they do not do anything about it, this lack of action is viewed as tacit approval.
This is why I decided not to focus on this aspect at all. I'd like to think that in the majority of cases, creators of remakes are driven by genuine love for the source material and not some ulterior motives, whichever those might be for freeware projects. Even if some remakes are weird, I think stuff like SF2IBM is cool in what that guy did with the limited technology available (he wasn't able to extract graphics directly from the SNES version so he used actual TV screen captures to recreate the graphics).
Also I think it should be noted that while the initial topic here was indeed mostly about "freeclones" and such, my recent interest arose from
unofficial conversions of non-PC titles to DOS, which led me to discover a lot of interesting games from platforms like ZX Spectrum or Commodore 64 from the 80s, literally "before my time" in many cases. Many of these are actually far more sophisticated -- both technologically and conceptually -- than I'd imagine for programmes this old, and in any case it's kind of amazing how people still not only have fond memories of these games, but keep creating new remakes and/or fangames.
I'd say that these remakes and conversions are a valid form of preservation of said games, alongside emulation, and they widen the scope of videogame history for those who, like me, have not had any firsthand experience with those non-PC platforms.