TX, on Jul 18 2009, 03:59 PM, said:
Heh, you can't just take Duke's CONs, art, palette, sounds, etc, replace/edit/do whatever with them and say it's "standalone" because you've happened to include modified versions of all the files needed to run. No matter what you do, all of your art files and everything are still directly derived from Duke3D. You have a GRP full of data that's either from Duke or directly based on Duke. It's a Duke TC. People should need to have a copy of Duke to play Duke TCs.
Besides, just about any Duke mod news posted will have a link to where you can buy Duke, because Duke4.net makes money from each of those sales.
What is left of the original CONs can be replaced or removed (though since they are GPL and thus freely distributable, I don't see why that is a problem in the first place). Replacing the remaining Duke art and sounds is more work, though certainly feasible. I'm not confident that will all be done by the release of the first episode, but there will be a total of 3 episodes and a full release that includes all of them. A lot can change by then...
The only reason we want it to be standalone is to reach as many people as possible. We aren't going to make a penny off of this and we don't have any ulterior motives. We love Duke 3D and want everyone to buy a copy of Duke if they don't already own one. But we know that most potential players won't.
TX, on Jul 18 2009, 03:59 PM, said:
No matter what you do, all of your art files and everything are still directly derived from Duke3D.
Have you arrived at some new understanding of what would be required to make a standalone EDuke32 game that renders it impossible? You didn't say anything like this about other standalone EDuke32 projects that have already been released.
As the lead developer of EDuke32 and as someone who obviously cares about this issue, would you mind laying out what would be required to make a legally standalone game that uses EDuke32? I know there are plenty of people in the community who might be confused about this and would like to have it clarified.