Laokin, on 20 May 2014 - 04:58 AM, said:
You're saying "Punk is about doing anything you want, except if you want to do x,y,z -- because if that's what you want to do -- you're not punk."
Also you seem clueless about punk, which is why you actually made the above statement... What is "Punk" has changed so much since it's inception, and TRUE punk is now considered "Not punk" -- The NY Dolls are the fathers of Punk music and literally zero "punk" music of today is anything like the NY Dolls. Punk was just mediocre musicians that didn't have good vocalists -- yet they played anyway because they enjoyed it -- they survived because their shows were fun, because they'd do other entertaining things while on stage as well as get members of the audience to partake in things they otherwise wouldn't do. People never went to punk shows because of the music -- the music WAS BY DEFAULT terrible, because they were all flunkee musicians that didn't give a fuck that they sucked. Just take a look at the Ramones.... Also, that visual style IS punk in terms of aesthetics, shaved half head, spikes, cut off pant leg, metal bra, bandoilers.... It's like something straight out of mad max.... When you measure if someone is "truly" punk, are you really saying "She's got spikes on, that's punk -- wait, let me inspect the spikes, oh they are dull... YOU'RE NOT PUNK!" ????
That IS punk. The whole "style" you're adopting -- promoting -- criticizing is NOT punk -- because the essence of PUNK is to be JUDGED NOT, rather than be judged, the essence of PUNK is to NOT judge, yet you're judging... It doesn't matter if you purchase something from hot topic or made it yourself, it's the visual aesthetic that makes it punk, not the brand behind it.
In other words, punk isn't what you wear, but HOW you wear it -- punk isn't a look, it's a lifestyle -- Bombshell fits this motif perfectly and if you disagree, it's you who doesn't know punk. The line at the end of the trailer about taking a rocket to the neck -- that's punk, the line was terrible, she delivered it anyway and just laughed about how terrible it was...
That's literally the essence of PUNK.
I wouldn't bothering answering to a self proclaimed "punk expert" who can't name good european punk bands.