DNS, on 28 February 2026 - 03:36 PM, said:
There is no confusion on my end. It seems to me that you're affirming what's taken place that's the problem: the blatant enshittification of the internet. Like I said everything is objectively worse now than it was a decade ago and it's indeed mandatory to use a platform like discord if for example you have a problem with a piece of software and discord is the only place the dev will provide support. Hopefully discord shooting itself in the foot, (yet again) will finally convince the sheep to stop supporting this nonsense. Although I highly doubt that even if a significant exodus took place that these users wouldn't simply move on to the next shiny flavor of the year walled garden rather than returning to the historically proven, tried and true format of an open forum while leaving the circle jerks in private else where. The problem of searching for information has gotten so bad that the same bots that everyone whines about are now similarly being relied upon to scrape for information via "large language models" that is then often hallucinated back to the user requesting said information in an outright wrong or extremely biased narrative. So no, it's not logical to be taken down a path of the dead internet theory coming to fruition which both examples of discord and youtube are symptoms of. I will never agree with that but apparently many don't have a problem cutting off their nose to spite their face.
Maybe my perspective has to do with living independently enough of tech that a lot of my equipment is at the very least a decade old (some of it two or three) and somehow I never had to go well out of my way into modernity for technical solutions, it would make sense those would be found in archives of websites too and not in present day Discord channels. But I have been observant of the phenomenon in different ways, for instance remarking that now it takes more private links or paywalls to directly interact with effervescent communities (but they are too effervescent for me), or it has become the go-to for project groups (out of pure convenience due to the responsivity, but it could be found elsewhere). An exodus definitely would just be crowds moving onto the next trendy platform which the Internet has seen happen countless times ever since the AIM/MSN / Facebook / Instagram / YouTube / Reddit... timeline essentially is the one of the masses being led by the nose from one competitor to the other, it would take a solid breaking point in the paradigm for the train to derail.
If I were to try and really define the problem I would say it is a much larger picture thing, for instance that privatization of the internet and pollution of information one can find just as omnipresent offline with gentrification privatizing and transforming former public spaces swapping out local shops for chains, or in culture just considering the relative brief history of filmmaking, T.V. and Hollywood just to mention animated visual arts (could be any form, for instance music be it as a whole or sub-genres etc.), really anywhere you look follows the same pattern that is because this system is designed for most any successful enterprise to eventually sell out to increasingly bogus entities that will no longer take risks in creative situations nor ever optimize in a manner that would be at the user's advantage in technical ones, and then once the public can no longer be duped the next magician in line takes over. Also all of the marketing on top in order to keep the bait fresh is a disgusting use of money. The power of marketing in general really shouldn't be understated when it comes to finding just the right triggers in people to have them act irrationally, is what I was trying to say is nothing so mysterious that is happening (but it always is healthy to raise the question). It is anyone's liberty to buy it or not but just from my humble personal experience in various industries, I literally can no longer question that we live in a reality that a big part of already was decided for by some of the largest corporations ten to twenty years in advance.